Tips for Performing High-Quality Peer Reviews
ثبت نشده
چکیده
Both now and in my prior role as Associate Editor, I have evaluated many manuscripts and peer reviews. Many of our peer reviewers complete reviews for a variety of gastroenterology journals, and we appreciate their service to our new journal. However, peer review of a case report submission is notably different than the scientific evaluation of other data-driven manuscripts, such as clinical trials or retrospective analyses. To benefit both the authors and the editorial team at ACG Case Reports Journal, peer reviewers should consider three key areas when constructing a high-quality case report review.
منابع مشابه
Peer Review – Legal and Ethical Issues Faced by Medical Staff: The Mandate for Physician Leadership
Physicians working in hospitals face challenges when it comes to understanding and meeting the medical, legal, and ethical subjects outlined in the hospital bylaws. Hospital staff physicians and the hospital administration both aspire for high quality medical care and the assurance of patient safety. Unfortunately, when quality concerns surface, there can be reasonable differences of opinion as...
متن کاملExtracting and Ranking Travel Tips from User-Generated Reviews
User-generated reviews are a key driving force behind some of the leading websites, such as Amazon, TripAdvisor, and Yelp. Yet, the proliferation of user reviews in such sites also poses an information overload challenge: many items, especially popular ones, have a large number of reviews, which cannot all be read by the user. In this work, we propose to extract short practical tips from user r...
متن کاملLetter of Editor-in-Chief
Dear Colleagues, As Editor-In-Chief of Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Medicine (JCTM), it is my pleasure to introduce this official quarterly publication of Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, which is an international, peer-reviewed, and English language journal. Our aim is to publish high quality integrating clinical and experimental research in the following fields: Respiratory medici...
متن کاملTip Ranker: A M.L. Approach to Ranking Short Reviews
Foursquare is a local search and discovery app where as part of the experience users leave tips, short reviews and suggestions to help other users find great places. This poster summarizes the strategy we use to select the best tips for a given venue. Our new ranking model leverages text, contextual and social signals to selects the tips that provide our users with the most informative and high...
متن کاملComparison of review articles published in peer-reviewed and throwaway journals.
CONTEXT To compare the quality, presentation, readability, and clinical relevance of review articles published in peer-reviewed and "throwaway" journals. METHODS We reviewed articles that focused on the diagnosis or treatment of a medical condition published between January 1 and December 31, 1998, in the 5 leading peer-reviewed general medical journals and high-circulation throwaway journals...
متن کامل